Page 1 of 1

LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Mon Jan 06, 2020 9:58 pm
by Radazz
Here’s a direct comparison.
Zeiss Standard
MD500 5mp eyepiece camera ToupView (some frequency problems)

Illumination
LED - RetroDiode Zeiss Standard replacement illuminator
Halogen - Wild Heerbrugg Hal lamp with transformer

Both fit into a tunnel on the back of the base.

100x
Antique slide Fossil Diatoms Circle Group Wolfish Bay

Image
Diatoms Wolfish Bay LED

Image
Diatoms Wolfish Bay Halogen

Here’s one from Mrsonchus!
Image
Mitosis root tip LED

Image
Mitosis root tip Halogen

35x
Acetaminophen Polarized illumination
Image
Acetaminophen LED

Image
Acetaminophen Halogen

Perhaps I should have run such a test before opening my mouth.

Enjoy,
Radazz

Re: LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Mon Jan 06, 2020 10:21 pm
by Hobbyst46
Radazz, I like very much this comparison ! thanks for posting !
Was the LED white (6500K) ? was the LED light filtered ?
On my microscope, equipped with a retroDiode white LED, I use a KR12 warming filter to reduce the bluish-violet tint somewhat.

Re: LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Mon Jan 06, 2020 11:09 pm
by Radazz
Hobbyst46 wrote:
Mon Jan 06, 2020 10:21 pm
Radazz, I like very much this comparison ! thanks for posting !
Was the LED white (6500K) ? was the LED light filtered ?
On my microscope, equipped with a retroDiode white LED, I use a KR12 warming filter to reduce the bluish-violet tint somewhat.
6500k yes.the first one.
Don’t have such a filter.

Also the two microscopes I use for photography are infinity, Olympus IX70 and BX40, both halogen,which sort of widens the gap.

Radazz

Re: LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Mon Jan 06, 2020 11:50 pm
by david_b
Very good, thank you!
The first LED image shows quite a lot of CA compared to the halogen. Is that banding on the slide?
And it's interesting how differently the colours are rendered in the last pair.

Re: LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Wed Jan 08, 2020 4:28 pm
by rs6000
Hello do you mind if I ask you more specifics on what your setup for the polarized image you posted taken from a Zeiss STd my zeiss does not have the pol knob function installed on the nosepiece limb, I have to hold a polarizer above the eyepiece to get the effect
I have not seen many with that option in the head but old catalogs do show this as available Ive just never seen on for sale.

cheers

Re: LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2020 2:58 pm
by Radazz
I bought a retro fit set from an auction site. Polarizer sized to sit on the field lens, and an analyzer that drops into the nose piece above the objectives.
Radazz

Re: LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2020 5:17 pm
by rs6000
That's a cool Idea Very nice
I thought about doing that but no filter I could find was small enough to fit as there is not much room inside the head
the method of holding one of the polarizers between your eye and the eyepiece is pretty precarious esp if you want to take pictures

Re: LED vs. Halogen test

Posted: Fri Jan 10, 2020 5:33 pm
by david_b
Here's my offering...

Image

Image